The Other Side of Murder is the latest Torben Betts thriller to hit the stage and, as a fan of a good thriller, I was intrigued to see how this one would fare. Set in the home of TV medium Darius Devine, on the evening of a family dinner when he is due to be reunited with his daughter, things quickly go awry as his pregnant lover turns up and his Gilbert and Sullivan-obsessed mother-in-law also chooses to dine with them. We watch as secrets have murderous consequences, with repercussions that not even a TV medium could predict.

Torben Betts’ book feels oddly familiar throughout much of the show, relying on some familiar tropes to drive the story forward. However, the angle of the TV medium and his ability, or lack of it, to confer with the dead adds an enjoyable and unusual twist. Equally, the last ten minutes are particularly enjoyable as the premise unravels in an unexpected way, although these more unique moments feel overshadowed by much of the rest of the plot. Whilst there is commentary on fame, marriage and the family unit buried within the show, this sits beneath the farce, and it is this element that proves the most successful. The story gradually escalates into increasingly ridiculous situations, and it is these moments that provide the greatest entertainment.
Despite some of the plot being predictable in places, the dialogue itself is well written and humorous, with both Peter’s wife, Susannah, and his mother-in-law, Miriam, getting some of the best moments throughout the show. The cast of five principals are strong across the board. Rufus Hound plays Peter, and the premise relies on him successfully playing the straight man whilst everything around him descends into chaos. He does this brilliantly, with a frequent look of despair and bewilderment that leaves you struggling to decide whether you feel sorry for him or whether he has brought this on himself. Equally, he is often found flinging himself across the set or onto the furniture, doing so with increasing desperation as the show progresses and heightening the farce even further.
Miriam is played by Susie Blake, who is hilarious in the role, frequently breaking out into Gilbert and Sullivan and generally leaning into her character as a slightly unhinged mother-in-law. Carla Mendonça plays Susannah, Peter’s long-suffering wife, manager and agent, and conducts proceedings with an air of authority that makes it easy to see just how Peter has become so reliant on her.

The set by Colin Falconer gives an immediate sense of place, with the design of Peter and Susannah’s home giving the audience a quick insight into who they are within seconds of the piece starting. Combined with Jason Taylor’s lighting design, Max Pappenheim’s sound design and John Bulleid’s illusions, the play is technically astute and leans into the thriller genre well.
Ultimately, The Other Side of Murder is at its best when it embraces the farce, with an increasingly chaotic storyline, some wonderfully humorous dialogue and a cast who clearly understand the world they are inhabiting. Whilst the more familiar elements of the plot mean it doesn’t quite deliver the originality I was hoping for from a thriller, there is plenty of entertainment to be found along the way, particularly as the final twists begin to unfold. It may not be the most gripping thriller I’ve seen, but it certainly has its moments.
The Other Side of Murder is on at The Churchill Theatre until 7th November and from then continues its tour. You can find out more here.
If you like this review you might also like my review of 2:22, The Mousetrap and The Play That Goes Wrong.